March 31, 2014 § 14 Comments
I flew down to PA yesterday for a talk I’m doing relating to my first book, and as always when I fly (which is fairly infrequently, thank goodness), I marveled at the whole process and how demeaning it has become. Partly it’s the security, of course, but even more so, it’s the way you can spend an entire day inside mechanical boxes, inhaling stale air, and drinking too much coffee in a futile attempt to thwart the narcotizing effect of it all: The machines, the weird smells, the sense of being herded at every juncture. Sometimes it occurs to me that an awful lot of people spend an awful lot of their lives in just such environments, and that makes me sad.
When I fly, I am never quite sure what to do during the pre-flight safety instructions. Is it rude to not pick up the safety card and read along, as requested? But if I did, I’d be the only one doing so, and since I’m already out of my element and feeling a bit insecure, do I really want to be the guy who’s actually reading about how “in the unlikely event of a water landing” I should calmly slide my arms into the straps along the bottom of my seat cushion, which conveniently doubles as a flotation device? Besides, once you start adding up all the “unlikely’s”: The water landing (unlikely), the surviving the water landing (very unlikely), the getting out of the plane before it sinks (not-exactly-likely), the not going hypothermic in a handful of minutes (are you kidding?), and so on, you start to realize how futile it all its, how it all boils down to the rude truth that you’re either going to make it to your destination or you’re going to die. I mean, is there really a chance in hell I’m going to end up floating in some body of water, my seat cushion strapped to my rapidly numbing body, thinking to myself thank goodness I read the safety card, while all around me the bodies of my traveling companions – who didn’t read the card – sink to their shared murky grave? Talk about unfriggin’likely.
I guess everyone else figured this all out a long time ago, which is why they don’t bother to read those safety cards, either. Or maybe they’ve just realized that if they actually read about all the unlikely things that can happen, they’d never get on another plane in their life.
• • •
I am currently reading over what’s known as the “first pass” pages of Home Grown; these are the edited pages laid out as they will be in the book. My instructions are to correct egregious errors only; it is too late for substantial changes to the text.
I don’t know about other writers, but this is the point at which I generally experience a bit of panic regarding my work. I have read it so many times that I have lost all context. Is it good? Maybe. Is it bad? Seems possible. Is it good in places and bad in others? Could be. Will I be mocked and derided when the book finally comes out? Probably not, although there are moments when it feels as if there can no other outcome.
It’s funny business, putting out a book. Part of me wishes it didn’t take so long, so I didn’t have so much time to second-guess myself. And part of me wishes it took much longer, so I could keep changing and tweaking and cutting and so on, which, given enough time, I’d probably keep doing until I got the whole thing down to a sentence or two. I’d call it a poem and my old man, who actually is a poet, would never let me hear the end of it after all the years I’ve been heckling him about writing poetry.
I guess writing a book is sort of like most things in life: At some point (and for me, that point is approximately now) you have to let go. At some point you have to trust that you’ve done the best you can do, and it’ll all work out just fine. Because there’s no safety card for writing books. And that’s probably a good thing, because of course the only way to make writing books truly safe is to not do it at all.
Funny how many things are like that, huh?
March 28, 2014 § 4 Comments
I’ll be away early next week. In the meantime, enjoy.
To Be of Use
By Marge Piercy
The people I love the best
jump into work head first
without dallying in the shallows
and swim off with sure strokes almost out of sight.
They seem to become natives of that element,
the black sleek heads of seals
bouncing like half submerged balls.
I love people who harness themselves, an ox to a heavy cart,
who pull like water buffalo, with massive patience,
who strain in the mud and the muck to move things forward,
who do what has to be done, again and again.
I want to be with people who submerge
in the task, who go into the fields to harvest
and work in a row and pass the bags along,
who stand in the line and haul in their places,
who are not parlor generals and field deserters
but move in a common rhythm
when the food must come in or the fire be put out.
The work of the world is common as mud.
Botched, it smears the hands, crumbles to dust.
But the thing worth doing well done
has a shape that satisfies, clean and evident.
Greek amphoras for wine or oil,
Hopi vases that held corn, are put in museums
but you know they were made to be used.
The pitcher cries for water to carry
and a person for work that is real.
From Circles on the Water (1982), by Alfred A. Knopf
March 27, 2014 § 16 Comments
A couple nights ago we pulled our butt-sprung couch up to the computer and sunk ourselves down into its pile of worn, torn, and forlorn cushions. Penny propped up her worn, torn, and forlorn appendage in all its raw and glistening glory, and we watched a short documentary I’d heard about a ways back called The Lightbulb Conspiracy.
In short, the film is about planned obsolescence, and one of the first documented efforts to engineer planned obsolesce into consumer products. As you’ve probably figured out by now that effort, coordinated by numerous manufacturers in the late 1920′s, was aimed at light bulbs. Apparently, many of the early bulb designs had a fatal flaw: They lasted too long. And because they lasted too long, they did not need frequent replacement. And because they did not need frequent replacement, consumers didn’t do what consumers are expected to do in the post industrial revolution economy: Consume. Or consume enough, at least.
As the movie documents, what happened to lightbulbs – which was to cut their lifespan by more than half – happened to numerous products over the years. Appliances. Textiles. Electronics, certainly. Still, perhaps the most profound example of planned obsolescence is the planned obsolescence of manipulated emotion. The vast majority of consumer waste is generated not because something wears out or is broken (although there’s plenty of that, too), but because the buyer simply wants something newer. This desire – one that is entirely fabricated by the consortium of mass media and the social pressures this messaging gives rise to – can be seen across a broad spectrum of industries, perhaps most notably fashion and technology.
Anyway. It wasn’t until this morning that I realized how perfectly the planned obsolescence of consumer products dovetails with something Penny and I have been talking about a whole bunch recently: Usefulness. I’ve written in this space about how important it is for children to feel useful, and about how enabling our sons to feel this way as often and much as possible is a defining motivation for our decision to allow them to learn at home. But just recently, and perhaps not inconsequential to the fact that I’ve lately been spending the bulk of my days at my desk and therefore not engaged with the land as much as I’ve become accustomed to, I’ve been struck by my own need to feel useful. And by “useful” I mean in a hands-dirty, sweat-streaked way. I mean with muscles and soil and wood and plants and pigs. I mean real work, not this highbrow pontificating-by-keyboard.
Anyway. This got me thinking about something I’d written in an early draft of Home Grown. For reasons that escape me now, I’d discarded it. Maybe because it’s not actually all that good, although reading it now, I think it’s at least fair-to-middlin’. Hell, I don’t know why I got rid of it. Maybe it just didn’t fit. But anyway, here it is, incomplete and unedited. But that’s ok, and besides, the same could be said of pretty much everything I write here. And it is relevant to subject of planned obsolescence, because I think feeling tangibly useful is the humanized antidote to planned obsolescence.
In a sense, being useful is planning for our own relevance, and I like that idea a whole lot.
Oh, and watch that flick. It’s worth an hour of your time.
There are many reasons to work the land. There is the real food one can grow, and the sense of vitality that comes of it. There is the luxury of honest labor and the strength of body and mind that results. There are the animals and the pleasure of their company, which is no small thing, itself.
But above all, there is the satisfaction and soft pride inherent to feeling capable. Useful. And with that feeling, a sense of meaning and purpose and affection for all the tasks that foster it. Because I believe that one must feel useful if one’s life is to have meaning. I also believe that it’s becoming harder and harder to feel useful in this world; amidst all of the smoothed over edges and polished surfaces of modern world first world society, one must claim their usefulness. It’s a claim worth making.
When people ask us about our practices and techniques, I often wonder if that’s what they’re really searching for: A way to feel useful. Relevant. Connected. I think that these good people, many of whom have spent a portion of their adult lives in work that does not satisfy them, understand that the reason for their dissatisfaction is simple. This understanding may not take the shape of intellectual knowing; it may take the shape of a desire to grow and eat real food, or to swing a splitting maul, or to build something, or simply to walk barefoot down the aisle of their garden in cool, early hour before the sun is high and fierce. It may even take the shape of fear that the modern industrial economy stands at the brink of crisis and that returning to the land and a simpler way of life is not so much a choice, as a necessity. Not merely for human survival, but for the survival of all the wild beings and places we hold sacred.
March 26, 2014 § 14 Comments
I’d just been thinking I had nothing much to say; the days are sort of morphing into one another in their snowbound sameness. Me rising at 5:30 to settle by the fire, nurse a coffee and bang out 1,000 or so words on the book before the rest of the family stirs, Penny thumping down the stairs in a hoppity way necessitated by her misadventure with the water pot, then out to chores while my wife irrigates and redresses her wounds, then breakfast, then back to the desk until lunch, then lunch, then back to the desk, then chores, then reading, then sleep. Crikey, it’s almost like I have a real job. Truth is, I’m sort of enjoying it; the style and content of this book is so different than anything I’ve done before, and for the first time it’s a truly collaborative effort, because as anyone who knows us understands, the primary reservoir of knowledge and experience on this homestead is not me. Pains me to admit it, but I am if nothing else committed to truth. Except when I’m not.
Anyhow. Here I was thinking I’d skip another day of posting, and then remembering all the generosity that’s flowed in this direction over the past couple weeks and with it a certain sense of obligation which I’d very much planned to avoid but what can I say? I’m only human. And then, this:
When you say “unschooled” what, exactly, do you mean? Do you mean something along the lines of child-directed learning (ie teach them things as they express interest?) If they never express interest in something, does that mean you won’t teach it to them? Is it possible that they’ll come to their 20-something years not knowing multiplication and division? And is this fine with you?
I’m not making judgements, just curious as to what your stance here is. Will these types of questions be covered in your book?
Ah, perfect. A question that pretty much writes the post for me! More, please!
So, first thing, yes, these questions are covered extensively in my upcoming book which, unless things change unexpectedly, is to be titled Home Grown: Adventures in Parenting Off the Beaten Path, Unschooling, and Reconnecting With Nature.
But quickly, I will say that we consider unschooling to be child-directed, adult-facilitated learning. The facilitated part is key, you know. As I’ve written before, unschooling in this family does not simply mean leaving the boys to their own devices, come hell or high water. There’s plenty of that, sure, but the greater truth is that we are often helping them get a project started, or ferrying them to their trapline, or arranging days with one of their mentors, or… you get the picture. Unschooling, at least the way we do it, is not for the lazy, although I sometimes wish it were.
Regarding whether or not we expose (I tend to steer clear of the word “teach” probably because I’ve always hate being “taught.” It feels passive to me and furthermore like something I’m being compelled to do. These are probably just my personal associations with the word, but to me, they’re real) them to subjects they show no interest in, it really depends on the subject. Like every unschooling family I know, we struggle a bit with math; neither Penny nor I are drawn to numbers, though we use basic addition, subtraction, multiplication and division every day (and no calculators, by gum!).
But clearly, the fellas have gotta learn some math, so we have imposed a certain amount of number play upon them. They don’t like it, but if we couch it in the context of their interests, they generally acquiesce. Would it be fine with me if they never learned this stuff? No, not really. I mean, it’d be fine with me if they never learned calculus or even algebra; honestly, I can’t remember the last time I used even a wee bit of that stuff, and I’m still trudging along. I still understand that there are three types of people in this world: Those who understand math, and those who don’t. Also, I’m confident that if my boys ever needed advanced math skills as adults, they could learn them, but I don’t feel as if their lives will be unavoidably bereft if they don’t learn advanced math. But basic math is something they clearly need to know. It’s a means of communication, really.
The only other consistent minor struggle is hand-writing. They don’t like to write much, at least not the physical act of putting pen to paper (they very much love concocting elaborate stories verbally). They both can write, and they’re getting better at it, but they resist. Again, this is something we tackle in the context of their interests. For instance, they just wrote thank you notes to all the landowners who gave them access to their land for hunting and trapping. Their desire to express their thanks and (let’s be honest, here) maintain good relations prevailed over their distaste of the writing itself.
To sum it all up again. In this family, unschooling = self-directed, facilitated learning.
Thanks for the question, Rina. Heck, thanks for the post!
March 25, 2014 § 27 Comments
My recent short absence from this space owes itself to a couple of factors. First, I’ve shifted into git r’ dun mode in relation to my forthcoming book with Chelsea Green. It’s like a meaty bone in my mouth, that project, and I’m gnawing like I ain’t been fed in weeks. I’m closing in on a complete first draft, and as a writer, that’s a fun place to be. Well, it’s a fun place to be if things are coming together as hoped, which in this case they thankfully are, though I suppose there’s still plenty of time for things to go to shit, so I’d be wise to shut my self-satisfied yap right now.
Actually, just a few days ago we got a thorny little reminder of how quickly things can go awry (this being the other factor relating to my absence from this space). Just a day or two after I waxed poetic about the return of consistent hot water, we had a couple cloudy days during which we used up the cook stove hot water on dishes and what not. Therefore, Penny, who desired (and certainly deserved) a hot bath, found herself lugging a five-gallon stock pot of near-to-boiling water up the stairs, bound for the tub. You can perhaps see where this is going, which is to a place of spillage and a large swath of melted-off skin along her right thigh. I was gonna post a pic of it, but truthfully, I don’t want to upset anyone. It’s real gnarly, multiple square inches of red and oozing leg meat. The pain is quite intense, and that’s just the pain I feel when I fail to avert my eyes in time and my gaze happens to fall across it.
So P’s hobbling, and I’m on for all chores and other physical endeavors, at least for the next day or two. And the boys are bickering a lot, all het up with cabin fever and pining for warmer days. And I’ve got this book deadline bearing down and it’s real freaking cold (ten below! In late March! That’s the real deal right there, folks) and yesterday just for giggles I went for a little walk in the woods: In many places, the snow came right on up and snuggled my crotch. That is some serious snow pack, my friends.
The other day I was walking up from dropping off the truck at Doug’s (the plow is still acting up, sadly) and I ran into Melvin coming from picking up a round bale in his tractor. He stopped, and we chatted for a few minutes in the middle of the empty road. About things broken. About injuries. About the snow and cold and our respective waning stocks of hay and how in this weather, the cows just won’t stop eating and who knows when the pasture will be ready for grazing, anyway.
Then we shared a rueful chuckle about it all, and why not? Because if the choice is between laughing and not laughing, as the choice so often is, you might as well laugh.
March 20, 2014 § 17 Comments
We dried off Apple last week, in preparation of an early June freshening. No more milk until then, though we’ll probably buy a bit here and there just to keep our kefir grains alive. Black coffee. No ice cream. Ah… I can already imagine how good it’ll all taste come June.
Freezer stocks holding out real well. Still have lots of pork, beef, venison, lamb, chicken, and even a few muskrats. A bit of beaver. Oodles of blueberries, strawberries, wild blackberries. Getting low on butter, will probably run out. That’s ok.
Everything in the root cellar holding up. Things storing much better since embarking on soil restoration. Lots of taters and beets, but ate through the carrots. Plenty of onions, garlic, squash. Gobs of kimchee and lacto beans. Applesauce. Dried mushrooms, dried kale, dried tomatoes, dried celery leaves.
Getting nervous about sugaring. Tapped about 60, but there’s been no significant run yet and nothing in the forecast. Looking like a short season. Real short. Soon as the trees start budding out, the sap turns “buddy” and that’ll all she wrote. The big sugar makers can sell buddy syrup to the flavoring market, but that’s not our bag. So. Might not have much syrup this year. Or might. Hard sayin’ not knowin’.
Most of next years firewood pulled to the landing, about half bucked and split, half still in logs. Logs are buried. Snow is very deep, too deep to work in the woods except on snowshoes. Tractor can’t make it. Soon as we get a thaw, gotta jump on the firewood.
One copse of softwood cleared to make way for perennial plantings. Another started, but delayed by snow. Many bare root trees coming. Many. It will be a busy spring.
Two lambs on the ground.
Two pigs getting fat on colostrum and milk. Warms the cockles of my heart, it does.
12-15 eggs/day. Eggs over here, eggs over there, eggs everywhere. Sort of sick of eggs, but hey. It’s what we got.
Chores are quick this time of year. They’re over too soon, really, just about the time I start warming to the task. It’s the annual lull. Normally there’s plenty of other stuff going on, but the snow and cold have put the brakes on most everything else, and I’m feeling a little soft. Erik called last week to go skiing in the storm and I couldn’t, but it put the bug in my brain and so Dirk and I hiked and skied the power line ‘cross the valley. Hadn’t done that in ages. I needed it.
I guess we all need something, eh?
March 19, 2014 § 20 Comments
I went out last night to visit my friend Paul, and we sat around his kitchen table for a couple hours, solving all our problems and furthermore those of the world at large. Sounds ambitious, I know, but it’s remarkable how manageable everything becomes when you’re tucked into a warm house in the woods of Vermont on a frigid late winter’s night. By the time I returned home at an hour that was late-for-me-but-just-about-dinner-time for regular folks, the sky was shot through with stars – how could there be so many, and had there maybe been a cosmic event, the news of which had not yet permeated the small cocoon of my life? – and I stood for a minute in the middle of the boot-packed path from car to house, my head tilted skyward. I was no longer tucked into a warm house in the middle of the woods; indeed, I felt a long ways gone from tucked in, but everything still felt manageable. I mean, really: All those friggin’ stars.
As parents are wont to do, Paul and I got to talking about our respective children. He and his wife have an 11-year old son, who seems like a real nice kid, though I suppose it’s possible he turns into a raging hellion when I’m not around. Paul’s boy wants to be a pilot, and Paul says he’s real thoughtful about it, actually strategizing how he’ll become one, what specific steps he’ll take along the next handful of years of his young life. Seems to me that wanting to be a pilot is a fine thing. I mean, who wouldn’t want to fly airplanes? And get paid to do it? Holy moly.
I had to admit to Paul that my sons believe they will be trappers and live in a cabin. Just like his child, my boys plot their future, though to be honest, the details seem little hazy to me. Just where will this cabin be? Hard saying. Who will own it? Tough knowing. How will they make a living? That one’s easy, because everyone knows you don’t need money when you’re living in a cabin in the woods and eating out of your traps. Do they think it might be lonely? Nah. They’ll ride the donkey to town every other month or so, and besides, friends’ll stop by all the time, because who can resist a trapping cabin in the woods, where all the world’s problems are solved by consensus and a pot of beaver stew is simmering on the wood stove?
Who knows, of course. It seems at least possible that Fin and Rye will at some point decide that growing old together in the wilderness ain’t all it’s cracked up to be in their 12 and 9-year old imaginations. It may even be probable that they’ll abandon this particular dream. But the truth is, I’d be fine if that’s the path they choose. Heck, I’d even stop by for a bowl of stew on a cold winter’s night.
I want to say that I have no particular agenda for my boys’ future, that whatever they do, I will love them and support them and be happy for them. I sure as shootin’ don’t want to be in the business of wanting things for my kids. That’s a perilous line of work, right there.
Still, I suppose there is one thing I do want: That whatever they choose for themselves, be it cabin or castle, trapping or trading, comes from themselves. That they are able to conduct themselves in alignment with their sense of what is right and wrong, what is almost unfathomably beautiful and what is unspeakably and sometimes unforgivingly tragic.
It’s not an easy thing to find, that alignment, and I suspect it’s not going to get any easier. Seems to me as if the world’s moving in a direction that makes such discovery increasingly difficult. But if there’s one thing I hope, it’s that my boys think it’s at least worth looking for.
Your support is always appreciated. Thank you. (Don’t worry: I’m not going to tack this onto the end of every post)